You miss a step. Your ankle throbs and your shoe feels tight. Are the ache and the swelling the same thing?
The acetaminophen in Tylenol Regular Strength can ease the ache. It has little effect on inflammation, so your shoe may still feel tight even when your ankle hurts less.
Imagine the same sprain with a different choice. Ibuprofen reduces the production of substances involved in pain and inflammation, so it can ease both the ache and the swelling.
These Advil Tablets and Motrin IB each contain 200 mg of ibuprofen per tablet or caplet. Taking both would repeat the same ingredient. Choose one and follow its label.
Switch packages and follow the ingredient to see what it can change after a sprain.
At the injury siteLittle anti-inflammatory effectIbuprofen can reduce inflammation
Tylenol Regular Strength→Acetaminophen
How it feelsCan ease pain
Local inflammationLittle effect
The ache can ease while your shoe still feels tight. Acetaminophen helps relieve pain but has little effect on inflammation in the ankle.
Advil Tablets→Ibuprofen
How it feelsCan ease pain
Local inflammationCan reduce inflammation
Ibuprofen slows the production of prostaglandins. After a sprain, these substances contribute to inflammation and make the ankle more sensitive to pain. Both standard Advil and Motrin IB contain ibuprofen.
Motrin IB→Ibuprofen
How it feelsCan ease pain
Local inflammationCan reduce inflammation
Ibuprofen slows the production of prostaglandins. After a sprain, these substances contribute to inflammation and make the ankle more sensitive to pain. Both standard Advil and Motrin IB contain ibuprofen.
Would you spot it on the label?
Question 1 / 3
→
Advil this morning, Motrin IB this afternoon. Do they go on the same ibuprofen tally?
200 mg ibuprofen in each tablet shown
Changing the box does not restart the clock. For these two U.S. 200 mg products, count the interval and the 24-hour limit together.
Question 2 / 3
↔
Tylenol says 325 mg and Advil says 200 mg. Does that make Tylenol stronger?
325 mg acetaminophen ≠ 200 mg ibuprofen
Milligrams measure how much of an ingredient a tablet contains. With different ingredients, the numbers alone cannot compare pain relief.
Question 3 / 3
11 PM yesterdayMidnight7 AM today
It’s 7 AM. Does a dose taken at 11 PM yesterday still count toward the 24-hour limit?
11 PM → 7 AM = 8 hours
Look back a full 24 hours from the time you are checking. Last night’s dose is still in that window. The dosing interval on the label also matters.
How much does your label say?
Tap a package to open its U.S. Drug Facts. These directions are for ages 12 and up, using the exact single-ingredient strength shown, without a doctor’s separate instructions. PM, Extra Strength, 8 HR and children’s products have their own labels.
Tylenol Regular StrengthView dose and cautions
In one tablet
Acetaminophen 325 mg
One dose
2 tablets (650 mg)
Between doses
4–6 hours as needed while symptoms last
Maximum in any 24 hours
10 tablets total (3,250 mg)
Too much acetaminophen can seriously injure the liver. Avoid other products containing it, including cold and flu medicines. Check with a clinician first if you have liver disease, take warfarin or have three or more alcoholic drinks daily.
Advil TabletsView dose and cautions
In one tablet
Ibuprofen 200 mg
One dose
1 tablet (200 mg). If one does not relieve pain or fever, the label allows 2 (400 mg) per dose.
Between doses
4–6 hours as needed while symptoms last
Maximum in any 24 hours
6 tablets total (1,200 mg), counting both Advil and Motrin IB.
Ibuprofen can cause stomach bleeding and raises cardiovascular risk. Ask before use if you have had an ulcer or bleeding, have kidney or heart disease, or take a blood thinner or daily aspirin. Avoid adding another NSAID such as naproxen. From 20 weeks of pregnancy, use ibuprofen only if specifically directed by your doctor.
Motrin IBView dose and cautions
In one tablet
Ibuprofen 200 mg
One dose
1 tablet (200 mg). If one does not relieve pain or fever, the label allows 2 (400 mg) per dose.
Between doses
4–6 hours as needed while symptoms last
Maximum in any 24 hours
6 tablets total (1,200 mg), counting both Advil and Motrin IB.
Ibuprofen can cause stomach bleeding and raises cardiovascular risk. Ask before use if you have had an ulcer or bleeding, have kidney or heart disease, or take a blood thinner or daily aspirin. Avoid adding another NSAID such as naproxen. From 20 weeks of pregnancy, use ibuprofen only if specifically directed by your doctor.
Can these two go together?
Same ingredientAcetaminophen + Acetaminophen
Both selections are Regular Strength Tylenol. Each tablet adds 325 mg of acetaminophen. Count all doses in the same 24-hour period. Do not add another medicine containing acetaminophen.
Two different ingredientsAcetaminophen + Ibuprofen
Some adults can take these two ingredients together. Each keeps its own dosing interval and 24-hour limit. Check other medicines and your health conditions with a pharmacist before combining or alternating. Advil Dual Action with Acetaminophen already contains both.
Same ingredientIbuprofen + Ibuprofen
Each selected tablet contains 200 mg of ibuprofen. Do not take them as two separate pain relievers. Count them together for each dose, the interval and the 6-tablet (1,200 mg) limit in 24 hours.
Does the limit reset at midnight?
Think back 24 hours from the time of the next dose, including doses taken yesterday evening. The date on the calendar can change while those tablets still count. Write down the product, time and number of tablets, especially if you use more than one brand.
What about children under 12?
For these 200 mg Advil and Motrin tablets, ask a doctor before giving them to a child under 12. This specific Tylenol Regular Strength 325 mg tablet has separate directions for ages 6–11: one tablet every 4–6 hours as needed, at most five tablets (1,625 mg) in 24 hours. Under 6, ask a doctor. Liquid medicines have different concentrations and measuring devices. Ask a pediatric clinician before combining or alternating medicines for a child.
Stop and seek medical advice if fever worsens or lasts over 3 days, or adult pain worsens or lasts over 10 days. Black stools or vomiting blood need urgent care. If you may have taken too much, call U.S. Poison Control now, even if you feel well. 1-800-222-1222
Pain, fever or swelling?
What have you wondered in the medicine aisle?
How does a swallowed pill find a sore ankle?
It doesn’t need to find the ankle. Once absorbed, ibuprofen travels in the bloodstream. A sprain sets off local chemical signals, including prostaglandins, that make the area more tender. Ibuprofen slows their production. Acetaminophen can turn down the pain you feel, too, with little effect on that local inflammation. That is how a shoe can still feel tight even after your ankle hurts less.
Why do people mention ibuprofen for period cramps?
That same chemical has another job. During a period, prostaglandins tell the muscles of the uterus to contract. Higher levels can make those contractions painful. Ibuprofen reduces the production of prostaglandins, which helps explain why it can ease cramps. Acetaminophen can relieve pain, too. The best choice also depends on your health and other medicines.
If they work differently, can I take both?
Some adults can use ibuprofen and acetaminophen together. First check exactly which products you have. Standard Advil plus Motrin IB repeats ibuprofen. Advil Dual Action with Acetaminophen already contains both ingredients, so adding regular Tylenol repeats acetaminophen. If you are considering combining or alternating medicines, show a pharmacist the labels and the times you took them before adding a dose.
Is 325 mg stronger than 200 mg?
In the U.S., one Motrin IB caplet and one standard Advil tablet each contain 200 mg of ibuprofen. One Tylenol Regular Strength tablet contains 325 mg of acetaminophen. These amounts identify the products. Comparing milligrams across different ingredients won’t tell you which will work better.
Took Advil this morning? Check before reaching for Motrin.
If you already took standard Advil, taking Motrin IB adds more ibuprofen. Follow the interval and limit on the label, counting both brands together. Acetaminophen can turn up in cold and flu medicines, too. Do not take two products containing acetaminophen together. PM, Dual Action and children’s versions can differ, so check every active ingredient on your own package.
When is it worth asking the pharmacist?
Ibuprofen can cause stomach bleeding. A history of ulcers, kidney disease or use of a blood thinner is a reason to check with a clinician before taking it. Taking too much acetaminophen can seriously injure the liver. Ask before using it if you have liver disease. Bring the packages or photos of their Drug Facts panels and tell the pharmacist what you last took and when.